Defensive Indifference

Okay, not really. But it is a trade: Brad Lidge and Eric Bruntlett to the Phils for Michael Bourn, Geoff Geary and a minor leaguer. Lidge actually didn’t have as bad a year last season as one might think. Despite the 8 blown saves, he did manage a respectable 3.36 ERA and 11.82 K/9. Bruntlett, however, will be lucky to make the team (67 OPS+ last season, *BLECH*). The ‘Stros get speedster Michael “Jason” Bourn who has the potential to be Juan Pierre with the ability to get on base (that’s not as big a compliment as it sounds). Geary’s a mediocre middle reliever. The minor leaguer is Mike Costanzo who had a solid season at AA and looks to be a decent prospect. So who got the best out of this one? Keep reading for more analysis.

It seems fairly obvious to me that Philly won this one, but not because Lidge is the best player in the deal (which may not be true when all is said and done). The reason this is good for Philadelphia is this: Getting a solid closer (provided Lidge can keep his walks down) will enable Brett “The Wifebeater” Myers, who was essentially the Phillies’ ace before Charlie “Dumbass” Manuel inexplicably moved him to closer, to go back to being a starter where he’s most valuable. Don’t forget, Myers will only be 27 next year and should be able to build off his 120 ERA+ from ‘06. No, he won’t be the ace with King Cole around, but he should be one of the top number 2s in the NL which is a pretty big deal in a weak league. By bolstering their rotation they might now have what it takes to get over the hump and do some damage in the playoffs. As for the Astros, they got a potential Willy Taveras clone and a middle of the road prospect. Yippee! Advantage: Gillick.

Of course, if Manuel keeps Myers at closer and uses Lidge as a set-up man I’d have to reconsider my ruling. But Manuel would have to be dumber than I think he is to do that.